Loeffler Randall Penny and Emilia Sizing Guide

I often receive fit questions on the Loeffler Randall Penny and Emilia style shoe. For reference, I am a 7.5/8 in US sizing and mostly a 38 in European sizing. After reading this guide, if you are still unsure, I recommend going to your local Saks, Neimans, or Nordstrom to try the shoes on. Once you’ve determined your size, you’ll be ready to pounce when you see a good deal on Shop My Finds. For more shopping and consignment tips & tricks, be sure to subscribe to the Thrift & Tell Newsletter and follow @thriftandtell on Instagram.

While we’re talking fit, I will also comment on comfort. The Penny sandals are 3.5 inches/ 90mm while the Emilia are 2inches. I would say the Penny are good for evening events, dinners, and parties. The Emilia are shoes you can wear everyday out and about, at work etc. with a dress or jeans.

Loeffler Randall Penny Heel Sandal: Order the larger of your two standard shoe sizes. I am a 7.5/8 and wear an 8. I can fit in a 7.5 but prefer the 8. Please note that I think the Loeffler Randall Camellia fits exactly the same as the Penny.

Loeffler Randall Emilia Heel Sandals: I think these run a hair small and I frankly feel in between sizes. I fit in the size 8 but they feel slightly small. The 8.5 feels too big though. I ultimately landed on the 8 and did feel they stretched a little with wear to make them fit a bit better.

Happy Shopping! For more shopping and consignment tips & tricks, be sure to subscribe to the Thrift & Tell Newsletter and follow @thriftandtell on Instagram.

---